BlackGeekdom

Science-Fiction from a Different Perspective

BlackGeekdom header image 2
← Spike TV 2007 Scream Award Winners Blade Remake Rumor →

Top 10 Sci-Fi Shows Canceled too Soon

October 25th, 2007 · Comments

Let’s face it, we’ve all had television shows that we wish weren’t canceled. But for some reason, science fiction fans have been denied quality shows. Actually, we do know the reason: ratings. You can go to any science fiction convention and still find people getting together and having panel discussions about shows that have been long gone. It isn’t like these shows don’t have fans or even in some instances started out with good ratings. Many times the shows were killed when the network got greedy and wanted to move a show to take advantage of high ratings only to lose the audience, or moving a show to get higher ratings, and the low ratings the show had disappeared. Sometimes, budget, production problems, or conflicts between producers and studios sent shows to an early death. Here is a list of shows that we thought were pretty good and were canceled before their time. Be wary, there are spoilers ahead.

10. Batman Beyond

Even though it was on for three seasons, we should have been given more of this very well written animated series. Set forty years in the future, Bruce Wayne has retired from being Batman and has forbidden his proteges, Batgirl, Nightwing, and Robin, from continuing their alter egos. Terry McGinnis, an athletic bad seed, and Bruce Wayne fend off the Jokerz at Wayne Manor. Wayne’s heart condition gets agitated and Terry helps him back into the house. Inside, McGinnis comes across the entrance to the bat cave and decides to come back later to borrow the bat-suit so he can seek revenge for his father’s death. Bruce Wayne eventually relented when he realized that Gotham needed the Bat and that Terry would be perfect.

The series is built on the relationship between McGinnis and Wayne, who guides Terry by communicating with him through the bat-suit, and serves as a father figure in Terry’s personal life. Which is ironic, because we later learn that Terry is genetically Bruce Wayne’s son. The show was so well received that it had cross-overs with Static Shock and Justice League Unlimited, and spawned a spin-off, The Zeta Project. Technically, the show wasn’t canceled; it was placed on hiatus to make way for the new Justice League series, though there hasn’t been any talk of bringing it back.

9. John Doe



“I woke up in an island off the coast of Seattle. I didn’t know how I got there … or who I was. But I did seem to know everything else. There were things about me I didn’t understand … the brand, being colorblind, extreme claustrophobia. And while my gifts provided answers for others, I still search for my own. My name is John Doe.”

The intro sums up the whole series. In the one and only season, we see John use his gift of knowing everything to help solve crimes. We also learn, though very little, about a secret organization called the Phoenix Organization. Aside from the rather mundane mix of CSI and Sherlock Holmes, the long story arc provided enough mystery to keep us entertained from week to week. The writers knew how to give us just a little bit of John’s story and purpose to get us to suffer through the crime solving. Whether this series would have made it past year 3 or 4 is a question we can’t really answer. But after finding out his best friend is the leader of the Phoenix Organization, season 2 would have been very interesting. Bouncing time slots and never gathering enough viewers brought this show to an end.

8. Millennium



Frank Black moved his wife a daughter to Seattle to get them away from the evil he saw everyday in his job as a profiler for the FBI. Frank wasn’t a psychic, but he did have the gift of viewing crimes through the minds of the killers. His visions allowed him to hunt down some of the worst serial killers TV writers could conjure up. Recognizing his talent, the Millennium Group recruited him. The organization was made up of former law enforcement individuals who consulted with law enforcement in criminal investigations.

The show started out as a straight crime drama but later evolved into the paranormal. (To be expected of something created by the man who brought us X-Files.) The show was well written. It gave a weekly serial feeling along with not one, but two long story arcs. The first story dealt with the serial killer sending Frank photos of Frank’s wife and daughter and Franks attempt to use his gift to find the killer, and the second story thread dealt with the true machinations of the Millennium Group. The show ended after three seasons and was wrapped up clumsily with a one shot episode cross-over with the X-Files that was supposed to wrap up a rather complicated storyline with the help of Mulder and Scully. Persistently low Friday night ratings brought this show to an end.

7. Miracles

Miracles followed a man who had been a priest who investigated reports of miracles for the Vatican. When he found out that the Vatican wasn’t interested in proving the truth of these miracles, he left to find his faith. Now, as a member of a group of people investigate miracles, Paul Callan becomes a miracle himself after being saved from death by a boy named Tommy. Paul sees the phrase “God is now here” in the boy’s blood. He’s informed that only six other people have seen this phrase, sometimes interpreted as “God is nowhere.” ABC only aired 6 episodes, so unless you have the complete 13 episodes on DVD, you’re not going to catch this one in syndication. I thought the show was well written, and if you watch the first episode you will be hooked. Despite the fact that 10 million people watched the premiere, ABC decided to change its time slot, not once, not twice, not three times, but four times, even sending it back to the original slot once. Let’s face it, humans are creatures of habit, and unfortunately 9 of those 10 million viewers never could find the show again. I even missed an episode because I couldn’t find it.

6. Dresden Files



Based on the popular novel series of the same name, Dresden Files was an original Sci-Fi channel show that lasted one 12-episode season. It was about a private detective who happens to be a wizard and uses magic to help solve crimes, usually of a paranormal kind. I really liked this show. It was a good companion show to Eureka. It was kind of cool seeing magic being used as an investigatory tool. (Charmed doesn’t count.) The stories were pretty good. The long story thread dealt with Harry Dresden’s culpability in his uncle’s death, and also his uncle’s role in the death of his parents. The minimalist effects were good. It didn’t take a lot of magic to move the stories along, and most of the magic use was practical. There was also hints of the politics of the Wizards Council which only added to the depth of the story. Don’t really know why Sci-Fi canceled this show. It had decent ratings for the network and a pretty good following (click here for the Drumstick campaign.) All is not lost however, it has been reported that the Dresden Files have been optioned as a graphic novel, for those of us who miss the TV show but don’t really want to read the novels.

5. Dark Angel

Dark Angel is the creation of film director James Cameron. It tells the story of Max (Jessica Alba) who is a genetically-enhanced human prototype hunted by her former military handlers through the edgy, underground street life version of 21st century America. Max is aided in her quest - both to avoid capture and reunite with her “siblings” scattered in the aftermath of their escape - by Logan Cale, an idealistic cyber-journalist battling repression and corruption in post-apocalypse. The show was a ratings hit for FOX on Tuesdays in its first season. For its second season it was moved to the graveyard called Fridays where shows seem to die very quickly. Fox justified this move saying that they wanted to improve the Friday night ratings and to open up Tuesday for the series “24″. Dark Angel’s ratings suffered to the point where its budget could longer be justified and it was replaced by another show on this list, Firefly. It would have been nice to see what the show would have become if it remained in its original time slot. Fox did a poll where viewers were asked what show would they like to see returned. Apparently, Dark Angel won beating out Tru Calling, Angel, Buffy and Futurama. However, Fox has not said whether or not the series will return.

4. Threshold



Threshold is about a secret government organization designed to not only hide possible alien invasions but to also stop them. The name comes from a plan design by Dr. Molly Caffrey, a high-level government crisis management consultant who creates contingency plans for emergency use. She never thought that her “just in case” idea of an alien invasion would ever come to fruition. Her plan called for putting together an elite diverse team capable of managing the situation. The appeal of the show lies more in the moral ambiguities of the main character and the rest of her team. In every episode they are faced with life or death decisions and are almost always making morally questionable judgments for the benefit of the majority.

The show was produced by Brannon Braga (Star Trek), David S. Goyer (Blade) and David Heyman (Harry Potter). The writing was good and the chemistry between the main characters was better than your average ensemble cast. Each episode was like a puzzle piece in a larger picture. Though the stories seemed to be self-contained, they almost always moved the long story thread. The show was canceled before the last four episodes of season one aired; however, you can get the complete series on DVD. The show had low ratings in its Friday night slot before the hit show Numb3rs, but rather than wait it out, CBS moved the show to Tuesday to boost ratings, a move that actually created even lower ratings. (Probably because people who were watching it couldn’t find it, or were already committed to a show on that night.)

3. Firefly

The show is set in the year 2517 A.D., following the depletion of Earth’s resources and an expansion of the human race into the frontier of outer space. The show takes its name from the “Firefly-class” star ship operated by the central characters; the ship’s class name is itself a reference to the appearance of the ship, whose tail section blinks during acceleration. Captain Malcolm “Mal” Reynolds is the veteran of a war of resistance against “The Alliance”—an organization that attempted to achieve the unification of all mankind under a single imperial government. A central “core” of planetary systems have fallen under Alliance control, while settlers and refugees in the farther reaches of space enjoy relative freedom from the long arm of the government but lack many of the amenities of a high-tech civilization. Mal now owns a small Firefly-class star ship called Serenity, making cargo runs and performing various other tasks—legal or otherwise—to scrape together a living for himself and his crew.

Sounds good doesn’t it? So, what happened? Fox handicapped this show from the start. IT marketed the show as drama/comedy instead of the drama that it was. The network also broadcast the show out order. What would have been the second episode became the premiere episode. Fox aired 10 episodes before it broadcast the two hour premiere episode (which gave the back-story of the characters and laid the foundation for the whole series). What should have been the premiere episode ended up being the series finale because FOX canceled the show after airing only 11 of the 14 filmed episodes. Firefly wouldn’t go away after cancellation. Its creator, Joss Whedon (of Buffy and Angel), managed to make a feature film called “Serenity” that was fairly successful.

2. Space: Above and Beyond

Space: Above and Beyond chronicled the ongoing war between the Humans and a mysterious alien race known as the Chigs. The war is the main arc and back drop for a plethora of smaller story arcs. One arc following the trials and tribulations of the United States Marine Corps Space Aviator Cavalry, 58th Squadron, or the “Wildcards.” Another arc followed the plight of the Invitros, the artificially created humans, also called “tanks,” as well as the Silicates, androids that rebelled against the humans and are now Chig mercenaries. We could also follow the political machinations of the new U.N. and the new united Earth forces. These are just a few of the story lines that demonstrate the depth of the story writing on the show. The strength of this show was its underlying motifs. The show encompassed subjects such as racism, prejudice, loyalty, sacrifice, revenge, and many other humanistic subjects and ideas, and they weren’t always related to war.

The military structure was much more rigid than in other shows such as Star Trek or Babylon 5. Considered one of the great science fiction shows of its time, Fox never gave the series a chance. The show had reached cult status and its popularity are evidenced by the fact that the second run on Sci-Fi had much higher ratings than the original run on Fox. Originally planned for a five season run, Space: Above and Beyond was canceled at the end of the first run. Fox killed this show by frequent time slot changes, preemption by sports broadcast, non-existent marketing, and just all around bad network management.

1. Babylon 5: The Crusade

This Babylon 5 spin-off starts just after the events of A Call to Arms, in which the Drakh infected Earth with a Nanovirus that will wipe out all life inside of five years. Captain Matthew Gideon is summoned to Mars, where he is to take command of the IAS Excalibur to begin a mission to find a cure for the Drakh Plague somewhere in the depths of space. Captain Gideon was handpicked to command the IAS Excalibur by ISA President John Sheridan, due to the fact that Gideon has proved that he is willing to take chances and would not let diplomacy interfere with completing his mission. The first challenge Gideon faced was assembling his crew; there was some reluctance about bringing Dureena Nafeel onto the crew as she was a member of the Thieves Guild; however, Gideon was able to get her on board. She then informed him of Galen. Galen met with Gideon on a planet, and after questioning Gideon, he agreed to join the crew. With his crew assembled, Gideon left in search of a cure.

This show had a lot of potential but never got a chance to live up to it. The show was going to follow a 5 year arc like Babylon 5. The series only lasted 13 episode before creative differences between its creator J. Michael Straczynski and the network TNT resulted in cancellation. The Sci-FI channel made attempted to pick the show up but couldn’t due to budget restraints. (Which is why all you people who bitch about wrestling on Sci-Fi need to get over it. Rasslin’, as we say in the South, brings in enough revenue to pay for other shows like Flash Gordon. OK, maybe that’s a bad example, but you get the point.) I really wanted to learn more about Galen and rest of the Technomages and to see the how they dealt with the Nanovirus. It’s a shame that TNT and JMS couldn’t find a way to make it work. I think we all missed out.

Sphere: Related Content

Tags: Articles · Television

Viewing 11 Comments

    • ^
    • v
    Some of theses shows were just a victim of being in the wrong place at the wong time
    • ^
    • v
    I think another problem was that some of these shows were out of place for the networks they were on. Look at what happened with Space Above and Beyond, Firefly, John Doe, and Dark Angel. They were all Fox shows that didn't perform up to network expectations.
    But when you look at Fox programming, a science fiction series doesn't fit in with the network's overall personality. Fox leans towards action and reality shows. What that tells me is that the Sarah Conner chronicles is doomed for failure if it has too much science fiction and not enough action.
    • ^
    • v
    I think it Fox should get credit for trying more genere shows than anybody else. Which also means they are going to cancel more. At least they try. I would argue that they tattempt to air more genre shows than most networks. You also have take into to consideration, hat fox has less primetime programming hours than most than the big three Look at this list of shows.

    The Adventures of Brisco County, Jr. (1993-1994)
    Alien Nation (1989-1990) - they really should remake this one
    Dark Angel (2000-2002)
    Encounters (1993)
    Firefly (2002)
    FreakyLinks (2000-2001)
    Harsh Realm (1999-2000)
    The Lone Gunmen (2001)
    M.A.N.T.I.S. (1994)
    Millennium (1996-1999)
    Night Visions (2001)
    Point Pleasant (2005)
    Sightings (FOX/1992-1996)
    Sliders (1995-2000)
    Space: Above and Beyond (1995–1996)
    The American Embassy (2002)
    The Visitor (1997-1998)
    Tru Calling (2003-2005)
    VR.5 (1995)
    Werewolf (1987)
    The X-Files (1993-2002)
    • ^
    • v
    I agree, but look at the dates of some of those shows. Outside of point pleasant and tru calling, Fox hasn't had any success with genre shows on the network for a few seasons. I give them credit for having tried more, but much of their shows suffered from a lack of marketing and sports preemption. I think that Fox has sort of established a personality and an expectation from their audience.

    Maybe those viewers they captured with shows like Millenium and X-Files have found their fix elsewhere, like Sci-Fi, USA, and NBC which all have had success with genre shows.
    • ^
    • v
    These shows were either very bad (you know which ones) or didn't tow the ideology line. Rupert M and his ilk has his version of reality that you have to conform with or no air time gets doled out. Art can act cleverly subversive (Millennium and the great Firefly).

    It's about power, money and making you think what the boardroom Yallies and Hardvard douchebags think you should think and what culture to have.

    Stimulating your imagination makes it difficult to insert those cultural phrases and images of consumer products, so they sell less burghers or cars. They need you blank. It works. Have it Your Way, Where's the Beef, Oh What a Feeling, Ho Ho Ho Green Giant, I'm Lovin' It, Zoom Zoom
    • ^
    • v
    Art has historically been criticized by some as subversive. You won't get an argument about that from me. However, that's a very cynical view of not only television and all forms of media, but it's a bleak view of the world. I agree that consumerism and capitalism drive much of the innovation that occurs in the world. I do believe we will one day be the world depicted in Rollerball, the 1975 version, ruled by corporate interests and mega-conglomerates.

    The point of this list is that these shows were good. There were many other shows that were terrible that were rightly canceled, sci-fi or otherwise. That being said, many of these shows were more or less entertainment for the masses. No more than the Gladiatorial combats of the age of Pax Romana. These shows were canceled because not enough people were being entertained to be a target for commercial interests.
    • ^
    • v
    Crusades was bad, the dialogue was stilted, and there were serious issues with the characters. I never liked the doctor that they used, she just wasn't tough enough for me to believe she would not have caved under. There were some fun moments but after trying to rewatch it again, forget it.
    Space Above and Beyond (SAAB) was the best written show I have ever seen, I just rewatched it and am annoyed that I can't see more episodes. Needs to be remade but god help us don't cast these "walking dead" female actresses as leads it won't fly.
    Notice how Star Trek borrows from B5 and how Firefly borrowed from SAAB.
    Firefly is my second best written sci fi show.
    Trek is wonderful of course but I mean, too many neat bows without enough string to make sense of how they did it. (Why are there merchants if there is no money and there are no need for merchants with replicators and some biomass, heck in the time frame they are in 20 and 21st century dumping grounds would be enough to fuel at least 1000 years of replicators, who needs the rations).
    • ^
    • v
    I find it hard to go along with how Star Trek borrowed from B5 when it seems to me that the opposite was true. Also, Crusades wasn't as bad as it seemed considering that it was a follow-up to one of the most popular Sci-Fi shows in history.

    To me SAAB was the best show on this list, but Crudades would have been even better had it been given time to grow. It probably would have been more fair to have them as 1 and 1A. And Firefly probably shouldn't have been ranked as high as it was considering that they had 4 or 5 seasons plus a fairly successful movie to flesh out characters and stories.
    • ^
    • v
    The way that Star Trek particularly Voyager borrowed from B5--spotted creatures (Neelix) American Indian (Chicote), Women having strong personalities and leadership roles, there
    was a lot more logic behind B5 then Star Trek, the Star Trek one shots are disconcerting in comparison with a logical story arc that has arcs inside that complete and move into another episode. Much nicer to watch via DVD then Trek is.
    The time frames were close, TNG was well before any of the others, but Voyager began in the middle of B5 and DS9 ran during the same time frame. B5 began in 1993, the show being picked up then had a run til 1999. The use of the

    although B5 did assemble a who's who of other sci fi shows. June Lockhardt (who stole the show during her appearance imo), Will Robinson, Checkov, the kid from the Partridge Family, The second assistant doctor (Sugar Dirt communications officer on the Saratoga), Crusades thief had various cameo appearances here before Crusades, Dude from a few cult shows was the mimbari who sacrificed himself for Delenn, the list goes on, and don't forget Nurse Nancy (Mrs Roddenberry herself who made a guest appearance on the show), also the voice of chucky and serial murderer betazoid seen in Voyager was a serial killer turned monk in B5.

    "I find it hard to go along with how Star Trek borrowed from B5 when it seems to me that the opposite was true"
    What elements do you think are borrowed from Trek?
    " Also, Crusades wasn’t as bad as it seemed considering that it was a follow-up to one of the most popular Sci-Fi shows in history."

    The writing in Crusades is pretty tough to get through, it shows in how the characters had to act. Also the Doctor was terribly miscast in this show. I would have liked a darker anthropologist too. It did falter in it's story line, but it was better than nothing, however, it is the one DVD set that I have not been able to get through twice, despite generous use of the fast forward. I liked using the thief in the episode where they find the other sentient species who had been infected with a plague like the Drak plague. And the air scooter chase was a great visual effect.

    "To me SAAB was the best show on this list, but Crudades would have been even better had it been given time to grow. It probably would have been more fair to have them as 1 and 1A. And Firefly probably shouldn’t have been ranked as high as it was considering that they had 4 or 5 seasons plus a fairly successful movie to flesh out characters and stories."

    Firefly only had one season 2002, which shows how truly great it was. I was not fond of the actress who played the companion in FF otherwise it was a flawless cast. Jayne was incredibly good.

    The only thing that might have saved Crusades is killing off the Doctor and putting in there a woman who actually seemed to understand the pressures she was under, I had a better feeling that she devoted more time to pedicures and manicures and her hair and make-up and tidying up then she did to any type of scientific endeavor. Really hated her on Mars side, the first episode where she tries to act tough was incredibly bad.
    Her attempts at physical fighting was worse than Lyta trying to punch a guy out mars side.

    I think the rest of the characters were salvageable as long as someone could come in that looked like a regular Joe and actually had a sense of what the hell was going on back in earth, instead of posturing.

    So often we go along with female character casting because well that is how it is, but it doesn't make it good and it doesn't make for a rewatchable show or series. Which leads me to top worst actresses in sci fi of all time. (not that the actress herself is bad but how the producers make her behave in the role is bad)

    3) Counselor Troi (did Picard ever get the stick out of his rear long enough to listen to any advice she ever had as a telepath that wasn't already painfully obvious to the rest of the crew?) I cheered when I thought they had killed her off in one of the movies (Now as an actress she is known as the nicest sweetest blah blah blah, ok that's great but still)

    2) I'm putting the Trill from DS9 on this because there is no way in holy hell anyone is going to convince me that a Klingon would marry someone who has been a man period. I stopped watching Ds9 after their romance, and I thought the romance between he and counselor Troi was laughable, (blech)

    1) Red Sonja Brigette whatever, nuf said

    4) The Doctor from Crusades -- her voice was so polite one wondered if as she was yelling at someone, that someone didn't just filter in a noise control that raised the volume only.

    5) The Dr. from TNG Crusher -- she made no sense at all except as a former friend of Picard and someone who could tap dance really well. She would have been dead within the first three years if she had been left to wonder nicely along in alien worlds.

    6) Whoever the hell the playgirl bunny was that Sorbo cast to replace Romy in Andromeda
    &7) Kevin Sorbo in Andromeda, let the women have their damn roles, you don't have to be everyone you wussy.

    Best Actresses in the roles that they played.

    1) 7 of 9 -- my favorite Voyager episode is the one where she is in charge of the stasis units everyone is put into.

    2) Captain Janeway, her performance as a captain was the best in the Trek franchise with the exception of Kirk, she went beyond best actress and is in my top sci fi actors.

    3) Shane from SAAB, I do think someone without as many mannerisms would have been better but she was believable as Shane.

    4) The entire female cast of Farscape including the bit players. Chiana was outstanding, the episode where she slept with her lover's son and was caught was one of the most memorable and classic Chiana bits.

    5) River from Firefly, usually I really dislike the "I am a twig and can kick ass" hollywood females of the walking dead, but she was just eerily on point with her lines.

    6) the Thief from Crusades, that really could have been a fun character given more time to develop with a more frictioned group on the ship.

    7) Romy and the Sun Avatar, they were pretty incredible until Kevin Sorbo (spit on ground) decided he could write and ruined their characters on the show. Whoever the new Romy was that Sorbo created for his dabble into porn on the sci fi network, go into the worst actress list.

    8) I am going to mention Kes because the actress did a phenomenal job with her, I personally never liked the role of Kes but I do think that the actress who portrayed her was phenomenal. I always hoped to see her in something else.

    9)There are a lot of good female actresses actually.

    10) Ivanava from B5 she added much needed humor to the show and was a memorable character.

    I know I'm going to miss someone I love but ce la vie

    The Bjorn on TNG and the Doctor who was in TOS and replaced Crusher for a few months added much needed tension on TNG and really made the show interesting for me while they were on.
    • ^
    • v
    Delenn until the 5th season where she fell into a sort of limbo of the actress lost deal. But she also said one of the most memorable lines in sci fi.

    "no earth ships who have ever faced a Membari war cruiser in battle has lived to tell about it save for one, he is behind me, you are before me............................ be someplace else.

    and they all turn tail and run hehe.
    • ^
    • v
    Top Characters.
    1) the captains sidekick in Firefly is one of my favorite all time characters. The Actress should have made it in my top five actress category list.

    2) 7 of 9, a vulnerable woman who has metal viruses in her blood stream that help her kick butt without flinching, yeah gotta love that. will tack on the borg to this.

    3) Captain Kirk, Scotty, Spock, Ahura, the Dr. Et al. I took Ahura out of top actress spot because it wasn't fair to everyone else. But she would have been in the top 5.

    4) The Undead from LEXX and forgot about the lizard slave from that series she too should have made it in my top 5.

    5) The entire cast of Farscape although Crichton did get annoyingly shrill in the last episodes. I often wondered if that was because he was the copy instead of the original.

    6) The Nietschean (original) from Andromeda, kind of a combo of Dr. Smith meets Coolio and becomes a greek god.

    7) the Invitros from Space Above and Beyond, will put in an honorable mention for the captain of the saratoga because of his guitar playing and introduction of a self into the show.

    8) Talon from Earth the final conflict

    9) the Dreaming Creatures from Earth 2

    10) The Avatars from Andromeda

    11) Starbuck from Battlestar Gallactica, she pulled off the role of Starbuck totally she should have made it in my top 10 female roles.

    12) Gkar -- and Londo, the entire run of B5 they were awesome.

    13) Reevers from Firefly, they were scary.

    14) Thief from Crusades was a character I would have liked to have seen again in another show.

    15) The Great Machine from Epsilon 3
close Reblog this comment
Powered by Disqus · Learn more
blog comments powered by Disqus